No Cost-Benefit Analysis Conducted for Alternatives

EuPC: EU Proposal on Single Use Plastics Will Not Cut Plastic Waste in the Oceans

EU politicians have snatched defeat from the jaws of victory with its Directive on the reduction of certain types of single-use plastic packaging, according to trade association EuPC


Photo by NeONBRAND on Unsplash

EU politicians have snatched defeat from the jaws of victory with its Directive on the reduction of certain types of single-use plastic packaging, according to trade association, European Plastics Converters (EuPC).

The organisation said that following a very brief negotiation process, what could have been a great opportunity to implement the Waste Directives’ rationale and to achieve efficient waste management has been transformed into a superficial legislative text.

The proposal was claimed to be based on a poor risk assessment of the possible environmental consequences and will lead to serious barriers to the free circulation of goods in the Single Market.

Yesterday, the three European institutions announced the provisional agreement on the new measures proposed earlier in May by the Commission to tackle marine litter at its source. To achieve this, the Directive on the reduction of certain types of single-use plastic packaging has been put forward.

According to EuPC, no cost-benefit analysis has been conducted for the alternatives that will most likely replace the items that are to be banned or restricted. Therefore, the possible environmental and health and safety aspects have not been considered. Alternative packaging, it argued, is not necessarily better from an end-of-life point of view. Furthermore, many jobs and production lines for local SMEs are said to be at risk and costs to consumers likely to rise.

“This Directive is missing a great opportunity to educate our future generations,” said the organisation in a statement which argued that without going to the root of the problems that Europe has in terms of littering behaviours and controlled waste management. If not plastics, other single use materials will be littered.

EuPC Director, Alexandre Dangis commented:

“The Packaging and Packaging Waste Directive diverts from its core purpose; and the desired harmonisation of all EU Member States is slowly but inevitably disappearing. It started with the Plastics Carrier Bags Directive in 2015 and it continues with another discrimination for only one material: plastics.

“SMEs in Europe are being penalized and jobs will be lost even though everybody knows the pollution is the highest in other parts of the world where more action is needed to combat littering. It will be difficult for politicians in the next years to show the added value of the EU institutions towards many of these affected companies and consumers.

“However we live in a political world which will hopefully learn from its mistakes but where education is taking for granted as the internet is taking over from our institutions.”

Against this scenario, EuPC said that it will continue to work with policymakers and NPAs to ensure that environmental sustainability as well as health and safety of products are guaranteed. For the above-mentioned reasons, EuPC still urges the Members of the European Parliament and representatives of the Member States to take the time to understand the true implications of such a proposal, that is far from ensuring the desired environmental benefits.

Read More
EU Strategy on Plastics Welcomed by European Plastics Converters
The Europe-wide strategy on plastics adopted earlier this week as part of the transition towards a more circular economy has been welcomed by trade body EuPC.

EuPC Survey on the use of Recycled Plastics Materials
The European Plastics Converters Association has presented the results of its survey on the current and future use of recycled plastics materials to its members.

IN DEPTH: Redefining Plastics in the Circular Economy
With growing concern across the plastics value chain WMW looks at a number of ambitious recently been launched circular economy initiatives.